Gold News

What's wrong with the Euro, Part I

Gold has risen by one-half vs. the Euro, yet still traders bid the currency higher...

RESPECTED ECONOMISTS never much trusted the Euro. Then again, respected economists rarely choose to grow rich trading the markets. John Maynard Keynes only goes to prove it.

   Infamous scourge of both gold and "the long run", Keynes more than quadrupled the funds of Kings College, Cambridge, between 1929 and 1945. London's stock market, meantime, ticked lower by half-a-per cent per year on average.

Keynes steered clear of currencies during the Depression, but no doubt he would be buying Euros today. If only the long run – "when we're all dead" as he noted – hadn't got him 61 years ago! Anyone worrying about the fundamentals, on the other hand, has to ask why everyone else thinks the Euro makes such a good bet in 2007.

"They're treating the Euro as if it was the old German D-Mark," noted Bernard Connolly of Banque AIG to London's Daily Telegraph last month, "but it's not.

"Germany has regained competitiveness. It has a whopping current surplus and can withstand a higher Euro: France, Italy, Spain, Greece, and Ireland cannot."

Why can't the "Club Med" countries bear a higher Euro? Just consider:

  • Spain is now running a current account deficit worth more than 9% of GDP; its housing market is tipping into freefall as Euro rates rise.
  • Late in April the central bank of Ireland warned that the Celtic Tiger's own real estate bubble can't bear further interest-rate hikes.
  • Greece took seven years to cut its state deficit below the agreed Eurozone limit, but too late; more than 42% of its outstanding bonds are due for repayment – or refinancing – over the next two years. Total government debt in Athens stands at 104% of GDP, second only to Italy.
  • Italy's failing productivity has pushed labor cost competitiveness down by between one-fifth and one-third compared with Germany in the last decade. As higher Eurozone rates entice fresh flows into the currency, Italian workers only become more uncompetitive in the global market for labor.
  • And now, in May 2007, the French have elected a new president who's vowed to "to launch a diplomatic weaken the Euro," as Le Monde reports.

"There isn’t a single country in the world where money isn’t a political instrument serving growth and employment," said Nicholas Sarkozy during his election campaign versus Ségolène Royal.

"Everybody else is protecting themselves; Europe cannot allow itself to be the only one disarmed."

"I am simply asking that we do with the Euro what Americans do with the Dollar, the Japanese do with the Yen, and the Chinese do with the Yuan. Is it too much to ask that the ECB push down the Euro to obtain a more favorable exchange rate?"

Trouble is, however, that the European Central Bank has been doing all it can to debase the Euro, as we'll see in Part II. Yet still the world's forex traders continue to bid up the currency.

Last month the Euro popped above $1.3680, up by two-thirds against the Dollar from 2001. Early in May, the Euro hit a fresh life-time high against the Japanese Yen. Way up there at ¥163, it has risen by more than 80% against the world's cheapest money since mid-2000.

Versus the Swiss Franc, old faithful of the world's top five currencies, it's climbed 13% since 2002. And since February this year, it has even knocked Sterling – darling of central bank and fixed-income reserve managers the world over – down by more than 4%.

Sterling itself had been trading around $2.00 per Pound, a quarter-century high of its own. One Pound in New York will now buy you twice as much stuff as it will in London.

Yet still the Euro wins out!

Whatever Sarkozy's simple-minded politicking might claim, Eurozone interest rates can't explain the Euro's ongoing bull market. Paying 325 basis-points more than the Yen, the Euro still lags the Dollar. Eurozone interest rates sit only 140 points ahead of the Swiss Franc – hardly enough to cover the rent on a suite of office for a hedge fund in Mayfair. On Thursday the Bank of England raised its interest rates to 5.50% – while the ECB stuck at 3.75%. Yet again, the Euro rose versus Sterling!

Then there's the money supply, that mud-covered fossil buried deep inside the European Central Bank's mandate by its ancestor, the German Bundesbank. Broad money in the Eurozone (M3) grew nearly 11% in the year to March 2007, a two-decade record. It's grown by more than one-half since the Esperanto became flesh and began filling cash-tills across Europe at the start of 2002.

The Eurozone's population, meantime, has risen only 3.6% in size; that's including the two million Slovenians who joined at the start of 2007. So in short, the Eurozone's now got a lot more money per head – just the sort of monetary inflation that putting the Bundesbank in charge of Europe was supposed to prevent.

"Independence doesn't mean indifference," said France's president-elect Sarkozy of the European Central Bank late last year. "We can't go on with the indifference of a certain number of [central] bankers who don't understand that the priority isn't the fight against inflation which doesn't exist."

Inflation in the Eurozone does exist, however. Even on the official Consumer Price Index, the rising cost of living in Europe has now destroyed 10% of the Euro's purchasing power since it became the world's first sovereign currency to lack its own sovereign.

Perhaps it should come as no surprise, therefore, to find that physical gold bullion has gained nearly 50% versus the Euro since the start of 2005. Measured in Dollars, gold has outstripped gains in the Euro by more than one half since 2001.

Adrian Ash

Adrian Ash, BullionVault Gold News

Adrian Ash is director of research at BullionVault, the world-leading physical gold, silver and platinum market for private investors online. Formerly head of editorial at London's top publisher of private-investment advice, he was City correspondent for The Daily Reckoning from 2003 to 2008, and he has now been researching and writing daily analysis of precious metals and the wider financial markets for over 20 years. A frequent guest on BBC radio and television, Adrian is regularly quoted by the Financial Times, MarketWatch and many other respected news outlets, and his views from inside the bullion market have been sought by the Economist magazine, CNBC, Bloomberg, Germany's Handelsblatt and FAZ, plus Italy's Il Sole 24 Ore.

See the full archive of Adrian Ash articles on GoldNews.

Please Note: All articles published here are to inform your thinking, not lead it. Only you can decide the best place for your money, and any decision you make will put your money at risk. Information or data included here may have already been overtaken by events – and must be verified elsewhere – should you choose to act on it. Please review our Terms & Conditions for accessing Gold News.

Follow Us

Facebook Youtube Twitter LinkedIn



Market Fundamentals