Gold News

Gold vs. Mining Stock Performance

Gold Mining shares have not moved up in line with the Gold Price. Why...?

THE DISPARITY between gold and Gold Mining stocks has shaken quite a few investors, writes Julian Phillips of the

Based on past market moves, they'd expected share prices to move roughly in line with the Gold Price in the belief that holding Gold Mining shares would produce the same if not greater gains. But with miners underperforming the metal, it's time to look at the 'why'.

First, and most importantly, what is a Gold Mining share? This is the most important question investors must ask, when deciding what to invest in, in the gold world. We have to recognize that a gold share is not gold. It is a share in a corporation that is involved with unearthing gold. But there is no guarantee that the Gold Price being earned is going to feed through to the investor.

The Gold Mining company – in terms of corporate risk – is no different to any other corporation. The risks involve employees, Directors, Unions, resources, production, cash flows, Dividend policies, to name some of the risks.

Now add to that market conditions (bull or bear markets), liquidity of shares in the market (which may have nothing to do with the quality of the corporation), and also price earnings ratios.

On the bright side, gold shares have the ability to perform better that gold itself for the good ones have a better profit capacity than the Gold Price (through profit margins) than gold itself. The income to a Gold Mining company accrues by the quarter or longer, so it is reliant on the average Gold Price over the period, for its income. And there is no doubt that a carefully chosen mining share that performs well in a 'bear' market does outperform the Gold Price over time and can be a better investment than gold itself.

Gold itself...?

  • Gold Bullion carries no corporate risk at all.
  • It is not dependent on people's efforts.
  • It has so many more aspects than shares in a mining company.
  • It is considered as the real money in many parts of the world.
  • It is considered as an important reserve asset by central banks.
  • It is unprintable.
  • It is a 'counter' to the risks inherent in currencies.
  • It is money, 'in extremis'.

But imagine Gold Investing from a professional fund manager's point of view. There you are, wanting to invest in gold. You look at the different options in front of you. Your task is to maximize total return on capital employed. But, you have to achieve this minimizing risk, as far as possible in the present investment climate. Unfortunately, the risk-reward ratio in today's investment climate is far higher than seen before 2007.

So now you look at Gold Bullion and gold shares. What points do you factor in? The first is that it is not one or the other, but can be both. Factors you would look at would include:

  • In the eighties, the Gold Price shot ahead of gold shares when it flew to its peak at around $850, leaving the solid gold shares far behind. Is today a similar scene?
  • If not you would likely look at the biggest most solid Gold Mining shares out there, after all, they won't go bust easily? But are they likely to live up to the growth expectations of companies whose growth of production is rapid. As it is the majors are currently struggling to replace waning current production.
  • A company that is expected to grow income, irrespective of the Gold Price, promises to perform far better than a major.
  • As it is the risks in all markets are high, so you may well balance this against an expectation of a higher return. Good juniors Gold Mining shares would likely fall into this category, such as the kind we focus on at There is no doubt about it, such shares would warrant the increased risk.

Of course, Buying Gold itself would remove a tremendous degree of risk, as opposed to Gold Mining shares, in extreme times. Many investors in the past turned to the biggest and most solid gold shares to reduce risk, saying they won't go bust, but that's not what you look for as an investor, surely? So you would measure one of these reliable but underperforming big gold shares against gold itself? After all, holding gold for the same period as one of these would give a similar return, would it not? This is because a gold share should, over that time, reflect the average of the Gold Price over the same period? In this case, gold itself would offer less risk and over time be a better investment, on a risk-reward measure.

But big investors go for gold itself, for far more than its profit potential today. When you consider that gold will rise in value as times get worse, whereas corporate risks rise dramatically in such times (see mid-2007 to date), then gold's additional qualities take it into a category of its own, way ahead of most equities. That's why central banks hold it and that's why very big investors hold it.

So, will shares catch up to the Gold Price? The answer to such questions is never as easy as we would like, because the world is never simple. In fact, there are a series of answers:

  • In extreme times investors shy away from equities, so gold shares would not keep up with a rising Gold Price.
  • In inflationary times equities in general do rise, as does the Gold Price. In such a scene, gold shares will rise and perhaps outperform the Gold Price.
  • When deflation is hammering values, gold will rise but investor capacities are reduced, taking most equities down with them, including exerting a restraint on gold shares.
  • Should an environment exist that precipitate a government confiscation of gold, then international Gold Prices will rise, but Gold Price in that country will not. Should gold mines in that country have to receive a government 'Fixed" Gold Price, then those gold share will underperform international Gold Prices. Post 1933, this is what happened in the USA.

So there is a place for both, in different economic scenes at different times. But one should require a good performance from good gold shares that will do well in bad times too.

Looking to Buy Gold today...?

JULIAN PHILLIPS – one half of the highly respected team at – began his career in the financial markets back in 1970, when he left the British Army after serving as an Officer in the Light Infantry in Malaya, Mauritius, and Belfast.

First he worked in Timber Management and then joined the London Stock Exchange, qualifying as a member and specializing from the beginning in currencies, gold and the "Dollar Premium". On moving to South Africa, Julian was appointed a macro-economist for the Electricity Supply Commission – guiding currency decisions on the multi-billion foreign Loan Portfolio – before joining Chase Manhattan and the UK Merchant Bank, Hill Samuel, in Johannesburg.

There he specialized in gold, before moving to Capetown, where he established the Fund Management department of the Board of Executors. Julian returned to the "Gold World" over two years ago, contributing his exceptional experience and insights to Global Watch: The Gold Forecaster.

Legal Notice/Disclaimer: This document is not and should not be construed as an offer to sell or the solicitation of an offer to purchase or subscribe for any investment. Gold Forecaster/Julian D.W. Phillips have based this document on information obtained from sources they believe to be reliable but which it has not independently verified; they make no guarantee, representation or warranty and accepts no responsibility or liability as to its accuracy or completeness. Expressions of opinion are those of Gold Forecaster/Julian D.W. Phillips only and are subject to change without notice. They assume no warranty, liability or guarantee for the current relevance, correctness or completeness of any information provided within this report and will not be held liable for the consequence of reliance upon any opinion or statement contained herein or any omission. Furthermore, they assume no liability for any direct or indirect loss or damage or, in particular, for lost profit, which you may incur as a result of the use and existence of the information, provided within this report.

See full archive of Julian Phillips.

Please Note: All articles published here are to inform your thinking, not lead it. Only you can decide the best place for your money, and any decision you make will put your money at risk. Information or data included here may have already been overtaken by events – and must be verified elsewhere – should you choose to act on it. Please review our Terms & Conditions for accessing Gold News.

Follow Us

Facebook Youtube Twitter LinkedIn



Market Fundamentals