Gold News

Gold Mining Shortage

There's a serious shortage of new gold discoveries and mines going into production...

about "peak gold" just yet, but the fact is that great gold deposits are harder and more costly to find these days, says the Gold Report.

Brent Cook, who produces the weekly Exploration Insights newsletter and brings more than 25 years of experience to his role as geologist, consultant and investment adviser, says that it's the occasional success story "that really keep all of us in this game."

Here he speaks to the Gold Report to offer a few tips for intelligent investing in metals and mining that don't require expertise in mineralogy.

The Gold Report: Back in January, you predicted that the economy would not improve much within six or even 12 months but that we might see a market rally. So far, right on. What do you see ahead now?

Brent Cook: We have seen a very strong market rally, stronger than I would have guessed, but I don't believe it's based on a fundamental recovery in the US economy. I believe a lot of it is a "relief rally" plus fund managers forced into the game for fear of missing out on their bonuses. People are out of shell shock and beginning to replace broken items and buy a few new things, but most people outside of the mining industry I know are worried about their debt and trying to reduce it. I believe we were bouncing along the economic bottom. Just because it's not getting worse doesn't necessarily mean it's getting much better. We've got severe leverage and debt to work out of the system, at least in the Western world. China's another story.

TGR: Sticking to the Western world for a moment. If things aren't getting worse and we're just going parallel, what will happen in the market?

Brent Cook: We had a massive rally from the bottoms, the biggest in 20 years, and I suspect a lot of that is due to the stimulus the government's throwing into the market. Government spending has added 11% to the US GDP this year alone and makes up about 40% of total GDP. How taking from one pocket to put in another pocket actually creates wealth is beyond me. But when it comes down to actual company earnings, just because they're not as bad as expected does not mean we're in for a major upturn in the economy here in the US When that reality of longer-term reduced growth hits, things will level off and drop back down somewhat. That's not original thinking on my part. I'm just looking at the data and reading various experts' opinions.

TGR: Since we bounced off such a massive downturn, is the market now where it should be?

Brent Cook: My investment paradigm right now is that we will see the Dow and NASDAQ and such back off into the end of the year. I don't see the real economy getting appreciably better, and I don't see unemployment getting any better. In fact, it's probably getting worse and it's hard to get a recovery going without employment increasing and actual consumer spending.

TGR: And what's your thinking on China?

Brent Cook: I do mostly metals and mining and that sort of thing. If I look at the copper market, specifically, I see copper's had a massive rally, from $1.50 to $2.50. From everything I can tell, that's based on speculative demand and inventory buildup in China. In my opinion, China is rapidly getting rid of US Dollars and buying hard assets, including copper and base metals. I believe China's investment is what's really taking the copper price up. China has a massive stimulus program going right now, pushing money out as quickly as it can.

The stimulus package amounts to something like 14% of GDP. That's a huge amount of money being pumped into the system. From there much of it goes into those speculative investments and the stock market just as it would here. That's resulting in a massive rally in the stock market. The Shanghai market's up 75% and Hong Kong is up 28% or so.

TGR: If China is stockpiling copper, won't the price top out here shortly?

Brent Cook: I believe it will. And then I believe during the remainder of this year we're going to see China slow down buying copper. At that point, I think there's a good chance we'll see the base metal market begin to decline again.

TGR: If China is the major copper buyer, can't they essentially manipulate the market? Can't they stop buying, let the price drop, start buying at a lower price until it gets to a price they don't want to pay, then again stop buying and let it drop?

Brent Cook: I suspect their motives may be a bit more sinister than that. Once they reach their inventory goals, the next desirable asset would be the actual metal supply –  the mines and deposits. By backing off, metal purchases prices fall; and we all know what happens to the market value of mining companies when prices drop. They're still sitting on $2 trillion in US Dollar-backed assets and to some degree it would make sense to plow that back into buying the mining companies. Why not do it cheap? That's just an idea, I have no proof; but what would you do?

TGR: Considering that possibility, what's your view in terms of investing in any of the base metals?

Brent Cook: I'm very cautious. It's a long way from a drill hole or even a defined resource to an actual mine. So I'm being very, very selective in the base metal side of things. If there's an asset selling at a significant discount to what it's worth at say $1.50 copper rather than $2.50, I'm happy enough to buy some and hold it. But I'm not aggressively seeking those, and I'm certainly not putting much money into base metal exploration targets.

TGR: Are there opportunities to buy the assets at a significant discount to the market price?

Brent Cook: Yes, I believe there are some. For instance, a number of copper discoveries have been made over the past five years, and a few of them actually are potentially economic. But the issue is the amount of money it takes to get to production. Money is still tight for major projects and the time and cost of bringing a project to the feasibility stage is daunting for a small company.

Let's say a company's market cap is in the range of $30 million to $80 million range. They've got $10 million in the bank. Yet to advance their projects, once they've defined a resource, it will take tens of millions of Dollars. To eventually build it will take hundreds of millions to a billion Dollars. A small company can't really do that, particularly in this market. There's not a lot of investment money available for base metals. Gold, no problem; but base metals, problem.

TGR: The Gold Price has held up well, moving in the range of $900 to $970 so far this year. We haven't seen a gold slump this summer, and a lot of people are saying it should take off any time now.

Brent Cook: I think there are two conflicting forces emerging. One, gold is up because of fear. Fear of another financial disaster and concern that the US Dollar is vulnerable. If this current market rally is for real and the economy does get better, I can see a lot of people selling their gold and silver ETFs. That's probably not positive for the Gold Price.

On the other hand, given the massive stimulus and quantitative easing that's gone into the market, gold could perform fairly well. I believe we're looking at serious monetary inflation that will eventually result in price inflation. And when that happens, I believe that's positive for gold.

If fear and inflation win out, the Gold Price will continue to rise. I personally don't know why it would rise dramatically over the next year, but I can see a volatile uptrend through the $1,200 mark over the next few years.

TGR: What do you think the market will do that would cause people to sell their Gold ETFs?

Brent Cook: If we really are seeing a recovery, with housing prices beginning to rise and unemployment numbers starting to drop, I can see a scenario where people begin selling their ETFs and putting their money back into the stock market. I think we have to see a true recovery first, however.

TGR: To your other point, about inflation and the effects of the stimulus on the Dollar, you're looking at gold holding up well and perhaps going over $1,200. What does that mean for Gold Mining if indeed inflation drives up the costs of mining?

Brent Cook: There's a serious shortage of new gold discoveries and mines going into production. It's interesting. Since 2000, the Gold Price has risen $600 or so, yet the actual amount of gold produced has declined almost every year since then. That's counter-intuitive, given that when a commodity price goes up, there should be more production. This is telling us something important.

We are flat out not finding and building enough new gold deposits to replace the roughly 80 million ounces of annual production. And if you view gold as money (which I do), the inflation rate of gold is actually decelerating while the inflation rate of fiat currency is accelerating. So we've got an interesting juxtaposition here between real money and fiat money. The real thing is becoming scarce while the supply of the phony stuff is effectively limitless. I like that scenario because it bodes well for anyone that can fill the gold supply gap.

That's me. I look for up-and-coming gold deposits – early-stage discoveries – that actually stand a chance of becoming economic. I'm not into the hype-pump and dump variety of discovery. There are not many real gold plays out there, but the few I've found are going to be extremely valuable. Especially to the major mining companies whose overall gold production profile has essentially been declining.

TGR: Are the declining reserves and declining gold production due to a lack of exploratory activity because it hasn't been economical? Or is there simply less gold to be found?

Brent Cook: A recent study by Gold Fields Ltd. suggests about $2 billion is spent per year in gold exploration; I suspect it is higher and have also read that the actual number is over $8 billion. So we are looking hard. The ultimate issue is that it's just getting harder and harder to find gold. We've scanned the earth over the past 20 years with satellite imagery, all sorts of different techniques from the air and on the ground. The outcropping ore bodies are few and far between. We are being forced to look where we can't see and that has increased the cost of exploration substantially while reducing the success rate.

Take Nevada, for instance. People are drilling 1,000-foot holes, looking for deposits that are under gravel and post-mineral rocks – the rocks that have been shoved over where deposits could be. That's an expensive exercise when all you learn from your drill holes is the rock type and whether there's alteration. Essentially what you could have learned decades ago by walking and sampling the surface now takes a 1,000-foot drill hole to get the same information. It's tough, it's expensive. That's why we're finding fewer deposits.

TGR: Is gold at $950 enough to make all of that expense worthwhile?

Brent Cook: Only for the few companies that actually find gold.

TGR: Would gold have to go up above $1,000 to $1,200 to improve that picture?

Brent Cook: That would help. Certainly as more money becomes available through the market there are more people looking, more people drilling holes, and there will be more discoveries. But, considering that once a discovery is made, it's a minimum of five years –  and probably closer to 10 –  before it actually goes into production. You've got to drill it out, do the metallurgical studies, do environmental studies, go through the permitting processes, sometimes deal with political issues and the money has to be raised. All of that has to be worked through. It takes an extremely long time. A company also has to make a guess as to what the Gold Price will be 5 to 10 years out when they actually will see production from the deposit.

TGR: If we take the politics out of it, are we at a point where we have diminishing returns of gold exploration? No matter how much we explore, we're just not going to find as much as we did before.

Brent Cook: I think you are correct. I think, no I know, that net-net, gold exploration is a money-losing proposition. You've got to be very selective about where you invest your money to make money in minerals exploration. On the whole, if you gathered up how much wealth was created versus how much has been spent, I think you'd find gold exploration and mining is a losing business. Remember that it was the people that sold supplies to the '49ers during the California gold rush that made the real money. Today that would be the brokerage firms, which win regardless of whether you do or not.

TGR: Then why we should consider investing in Gold Mining companies?

Brent Cook: Because the few that actually find economic, high-margin deposits make a lot of money. We're talking companies that can increase 10-, 100-, even 1,000-fold based on legitimate discoveries. It's those few big wins that really keep all of us in this game and keep all the money coming in.

TGR: What do you mean by "a few"?

Brent Cook: There are more than 2,000 junior mining and exploration companies listed around the world, and most of them are out there looking for gold. Maybe 1% of them are going to find a deposit that actually makes good money. You can make money on the perception of the discovery with maybe another 15% of those companies if you are nimble and recognize the difference between reality and hype. And the rest of them, the 84%, you lose money on in the long run.

TGR: Your geology background would come in handy in isolating those precious few. Can you share with us some of the companies that have the potential to find such deposits and convert them into mines?

Brent Cook: Let's see. Who's out there that I think is doing good work and whose stock hasn't taken off yet? A lot of companies are doing good work. Let's go to Nevada; it's one of the premier gold provinces but it's a very difficult place to explore. Long Canyon is a new Carlin-style discovery and surprisingly near surface. They drilled out a little over 800,000 ounces of very good grade material, and that has a potential to turn into a much larger deposit. Fronteer is running the program now and they're just beginning to understand the geologic controls and should be able to start drilling some deeper holes within the next month or two. The source or feeder for the near surface deposit is unknown. That unknown is a very good exploration target and one that could potentially be a major deposit. There is also a lot of potentially mineralized ground that lies under gravel or on trend that has not even been looked at. Potentially, if they find that source, we could be seeing the beginning of a new Carlin-style trend.

TGR: What makes Nevada the premier place to be?

Brent Cook: The amount of gold in Nevada is quite remarkable. It's a gold province and the deposits there can be massive, especially these Carlin-style systems. The Carlin Trend alone has over 70 million ounces and individual deposits host tens of millions of ounces. If you can find one of those, it's very profitable. If you can do it in a tiny $15million Dollar market cap company, well, I'm buying the next round. When you look at Barrick Gold Corporation (NYSE:ABX) and Newmont Mining Corp. (NYSE:NEM), that's where they started. Barrick is still finding deposits in Nevada. In this decade, they've discovered of about 15 million ounces on ground they've had for 25 years. The deposits are there. They just take a lot of work. That's why I think Nevada is one of the better places to be, plus you know the politics, the infrastructure is good, and you can always get a cold beer.

In terms of a person's portfolio, the exploration side of things is certainly a high-risk proposition, but I think it can be done intelligently. A person needs to really put the work into understanding what exploration is all about, how it works, and then correctly interpreting results. If you can do that you outsmart three fourths of the competition.

I would say half of my portfolio is in the exploration sector. In the newsletter we started, what I called a gamblin' stock portfolio in May, is up better than 140% on six stocks –  more if you consider the two dogs I indicated didn't have much of a chance. So it's a good sector for me to be in, and I think in particular gold discoveries are going to be worth a lot more as we move forward. We already discussed the decline in global production and major mining companies needing to replace their reserves. So intelligent investing in the speculative side of minerals exploration is a smart place to be, if you are informed about it.

One thing any investor could do is when a news release comes out or when they're investigating a company, go to the website and see what's there. The website and disclosure provided tells you a lot about a company. Make sure that when a company reports drill results, for instance, that a map's included. They need to report all the drill holes. Often a company reports results from hole numbers 5, 8 and 20. Okay, there's 17 holes there we're not hearing about. Why aren't they reported, and what was drilled in the past? Just seeing how a company discloses information can tell you whether they're honest or not. I think that test alone cuts out half the companies; you won't need to bother with them. If a company doesn't fully report information, assume they're hiding something. Anybody can do that easy test. You don't even need to know what the information means, just know whether they present and report everything.

TGR: Anything else you want to pop in here before we say goodbye?

Brent Cook: In summary, I think I'd just say gold exploration is a good sector to be in, albeit only with your risk capital. Exploration success offers the highest possible returns if you are careful; a bit of luck doesn't hurt either. But you have to be intelligent about it.

Ready to Buy  Gold but unsure how to do it? Cut your costs without compromising safety or convenience at BullionVault...

The Gold Report is a unique, free site featuring summaries of articles from major publications, specific recommendations from top worldwide analysts and portfolio managers covering gold stocks, and a directory, with samples, of precious metals newsletters. 

See the full archive of Gold Report articles.

Please Note: All articles published here are to inform your thinking, not lead it. Only you can decide the best place for your money, and any decision you make will put your money at risk. Information or data included here may have already been overtaken by events – and must be verified elsewhere – should you choose to act on it. Please review our Terms & Conditions for accessing Gold News.

Follow Us

Facebook Youtube Twitter LinkedIn



Market Fundamentals