Five Minutes to Midnight
The Fed could start raising rates inside 3 months. The upshot for Gold Prices...?
"AS THE OLD saying goes, what the wise man does at the beginning, fools do in the end," said Warren Buffett, at Berkshire Hathaway's Annual Meeting, in May 2006, notes Gary Dorsch at Global Money Trends.
"It's like Cinderella at the ball. You know that at midnight everything's going to turn back to pumpkins and mice. But you look around and say, one more dance, and so does everyone else. Everyone thinks they'll get out at midnight. The party does get more fun, dance partners get prettier, – one more glass of champagne. And besides, there are no clocks on the wall. And then suddenly, the clock strikes twelve...and everything turns back to pumpkins and mice..."
Now there's a multitude of speculators engaging in the US Dollar carry trade, all betting that they'll reach the exit door first, before the clock strikes midnight – or when the Fed begins to tighten liquidity.
However, recent signs that the US economy is rebounding from its two-year slump, at a much faster pace than expected, have widened the US Treasury's yield curve to its steepest level in more than two decades. That's a sure sign that Fed rates won't stay pegged near zero percent much longer, and that higher interest rates lie ahead in 2010.
Although the Yield Curve is signaling that the clock will strike midnight as early as Q2 2010, Fed officials continue to implore US Dollar carry traders to dance on the Dollar's grave awhile longer.
"The recession now appears to be over, but the economy is still weak and the unemployment rate is much too high," said NY Fed chief William Dudley on Dec 7th.
"These circumstances underpin the Fed's commitment to keeping short-term rates exceptionally low for an extended period."
Dudley says the US economy still faces "quite a few headwinds generated by the hangover of the financial crisis. Banks are still under pressure from credit losses, and the shadow banking system is impaired.
"Next year, growth will be slightly weaker, as fiscal stimulus fades," he explained. Dudley emphasizes that the Fed has the ability to exit smoothly from its extraordinary stimulus, when the time arrives, but that day of reckoning is still several months away.
Still, over-extended US Dollar carry traders began scaling back their bets on Dec 4th, after US Labor apparatchiks shocked the market by reporting that 11,000 jobs were lost in November, far less than what was expected, and the best showing for the jobs market since the "Great Recession" began.
The Dept. of Labor skewed the numbers further, figuring that 159,000 fewer jobs were lost in September and October than previously reported. Four sectors, including the government, added jobs.
Since the Labor apparatchiks unleashed their bombshell report, yields on the US Treasury's 5-year note have risen by 30-basis points, up to around 2.30% today, which in turn, had the effect of lifting the US Dollar index higher. How? Beijing has often voiced its dismay over the Fed's policy of printing money to buy Treasury debt, and Japan's Ministry of Finance is greatly disturbed by the Dollar's slide under ¥90, which threatens to choke-off its export led recovery.
Thus, behind the scenes, America's two largest creditors might be demanding a credible defense of the US Dollar by the Treasury, which can only be engineered with higher interest rates.
As experts debate the potential speed of the US recovery, one figure looms large but is often overlooked:
Nearly 1 in 5 Americans is either out of a job, too discouraged to look for a job, or working part-time, at a lesser wage.
According to Labor's broadest measure of unemployment, the U-6 jobless rate is 17.2%, the highest since the Great Depression of the 1930s. Still, bond traders are looking through the front view window, not backwards, and see job creation returning next year.
Bond-market vigilantes are therefore monitoring developments on the labor front, and have jacked-up 30-year Treasury yields to 4.55% today, on expectations of a tighter Fed policy starting next year. Since 1954, the Fed has raised rates only after unemployment has peaked. On October 12th, St Louis Fed chief James Bullard said a falling unemployment rate is a precondition for an up-tick in the federal funds rate from near zero.
"You want some jobs growth and unemployment coming down. That is a prerequisite for an increase in interest rates. It doesn't mean you need unemployment all the way down to more normal levels."
After the last two recessions the Greenspan-Bernanke Fed waited for two-and-a-half years before tightening. That has fueled criticism that the Fed is quick to slash rates when the stock market is plunging, but slow to raise rates when the stock market is going up. The outcome of this asymmetrical monetary policy is the emergence of asset bubbles, "boom and bust" cycles, and wild roller coaster rides in the markets.
Either way, time is running out on the Fed's ultra-easy money scheme, after US producer prices rose more than expected in November, lifted by a surge in energy costs, and recording the first year-on-year gain since last November.
Prices paid at the farm and factories were 1.8% higher than a year ago on the official data, following a 0.3% rise in October. So for now, the Bernanke Fed has averted the threat of a deflationary spiral, thanks to its electronic printing press. And the sharp up-turn in the Producer Price Index (PPI) isn't a surprise to commodity watchers, who track key indicators. The Dow Jones Commodity Index now stands 25% higher than a year ago. The Reuters-CRB Commodity Index is up 39% from a year ago, benefitting from the US Dollar's index's slide of 9.1% over the same period on the currency markets.
But if the Fed and US Treasury allow the Dollar to fall further, American households would get slammed by a double whammy – a lack of job availability and higher commodity prices, for food and energy.
Philadelphia Fed chief Charles Plosser acknowledges that food and energy price shocks can fuel inflation in a way that could become a self-fulfilling prophecy. However, "Central banks should not respond to wild swings in food and energy prices with monetary policy unless expectations of inflation become unhinged," he said on Nov 19th.
Chicago Fed chief Charles Evans agrees, saying on Nov 13th, "As long as we can't detect bubbles with great confidence, it seems unwise to adopt fighting them as a policy objective," he said, ruling out higher rates to prick bubbles.
Instead, the Fed is calling upon Congress and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) to rein in energy and commodity prices, especially crude oil, by limiting how many futures contracts hedge funds, investment banks and other speculators can control in 2010. However, Terry Duffy, chief of the CME commodity exchange group, says the CFTC's attempts to curb participation in a regulated marketplace could backfire.
"What they are going to do is to drive business out to an unregulated OTC platform [with traders dealing directly with each other 'over the counter', rather than through a recognized formal exchange platform] whether it's in the US, through an exchange traded fund [i.e. ETFs on the stock market], or a European or Asian entity."
In remarks to the Economic Club of New York on Nov 16th, Fed chief Ben "Bubbles" Bernanke commented on the US Dollar and its impact on inflation.
"Early warnings of actual inflation must be monitored carefully. Commodities prices have risen lately, reflecting the pickup in global economic activity, especially in resource-intensive emerging market economies, and the recent depreciation of the Dollar. We are attentive to the implications of changes in the value of the Dollar, and will continue to formulate policy to guard against risks to our dual mandate to foster both maximum employment and price stability..."
Few traders took Mr Bernanke's comments seriously, and a week later, the Dollar was plunging to a 14-year low of ¥85. The Bank of Japan began a solo effort to defend the US Dollar, pumping ¥10 trillion ($115 billion) into short-term bank deposits on Dec 1st, flooding the system with Yen, and in turn forcing US Dollar carry traders to cover over-extended short positions.
"If there is a shortage of liquidity we are prepared to provide more funds," Shirakawa warned, driving Japan's five-year yield to 0.45%, a four-year low.
However, the Bank of Japan's intervention to defend the Dollar failed to get the same "bang for the buck" as the 35-basis point up-tick in US Treasury 5-year yields. Small tweaking of interest rates can have noticeable results in the foreign exchange market, where $4 trillion of fiat paper changes hands each day. Following the Labor Department's double barreled dose of Dollar-friendly news, the yield on the US Treasury's 2-year note jumped 25-basis points to 70 points above Japanese 2-year yields, elevating the US Dollar towards ¥90.
Tokyo's financial warlords have drawn a line in the sand at ¥88.25, where they aim to build a floor for the US Dollar.
Yet a stronger Yen does have a big silver lining, anchoring Japanese bond (JGB) yields near record lows, and lowering the cost of financing Japan's outstanding debt. Hirohisa Fujii, Japan's finance minister said on Dec 8th that new JGB issuance will hit a record ¥53 trillion ($593 billion) in the year ending March, making-up for a plunge in tax revenue.
"We would lose the confidence of the JGB market if Japan was to recklessly issue bonds," Fujii said. "We will make every effort to keep that from happening."
The International Monetary Fund (IMF) says Japan's public debt could reach 227% of the size of its economy in 2010, greater than the annual output of Germany, France, Britain, and Canada combined. Japan's government has lived beyond its means since the 1990s thanks to a massive pool of domestic savings. Households own ¥1,440 trillion ($16.3 trillion) in assets, mostly deposited in banks, which then buy government bonds. Foreigners only hold about 8% of outstanding JGBs.
Shortly after the Bank of Japan injected ¥10 trillion into the Tokyo money market, the price of Gold in New York rose above the $1200-per-ounce level for the first time ever.
Likewise, the US Treasury's yield curve, measuring the spread between rates on 30-year and 2-year notes, rose to 374 basis points, up sharply from around 305 bp in late September, when gold was trading near $990.
The shape of the yield curve reflects the notion that the Fed has taken short-term rates as low as possible and the next shift will inevitably be upwards. Coinciding with sharply higher Gold Prices, the steep curve suggests fear of higher inflation in the future. The slope of the curve doesn't necessarily reflect the weight of $12 trillion of outstanding supply in the US government bond market. But Treasury bond prices would probably surge higher, and yields would plummet amid a flight for safety, if the US stock market was to suddenly begin to meltdown again.
When asked about recent market gyrations on Dec 15th, Ben Bernanke argued that the recent rise in Gold Prices was not a sign of increasing inflation expectations.
"Increases in prices of gold and other commodity over the past few months appear to reflect the recovery of the global economy, and it is not clear they have been out of line with fundamentals..."
However, such convenient, and self-serving commentaries by "Bubbles" Bernanke is a prime example of the Fed's spin operations and propaganda that is readily soaked up by the media, and in turn, is utilized to brainwash the general public.
Global financial markets have a lot of moving parts, and it's very difficult for anyone to fully encapsulate all the factors that are weighed into any single forecast.
That's why it's very important to keep an open mind about all possible outcomes, while continuing to gather the facts, conduct analysis, and form an opinion, and conceding one could be wrong. While the general consensus believes the Fed won't lift rates until late in 2010, it's the contrarian view which might prevail next year, with the Fed hiking short-term interest rates sooner rather than later.
Former Fed chief Paul Volcker said on Oct 15th it was difficult, "but necessary, for the Fed to start draining the billions of Dollars in liquidity even while unemployment remains high as the US battles out of recession. You have to act against what seems like common sense. If you wait, it's too late," he warned.
Two months later, the Bernanke Fed is still signaling ultra-low rates for an extended period of time. But would a campaign of baby-step Fed rate hikes knock the Gold Price off its upward trajectory?
Gold tumbled by nearly 10% from its all-time high of $1226 an ounce in recent weeks, driven down by ideas that Fed rate hikes might come sooner rather than later, as suggested by the yield curve. For chartists, the latest slump in gold is a classic removal of speculative froth, which normally follows a parabolic rise.
Yet if history is a guide to the future, the gold market has been able to climb sharply higher alongside a rising fed funds rate. The Fed's last rate hiking cycle – starting in June 2004, and beginning with the fed funds rate at 1% – wasn't able to cap gold's powerful advance through May 2006, right up until the fed funds rate was lifted to 5.25%.
Thus for two years, gold rose 40% alongside a 425-basis point increase in the fed funds rate. Because the Fed was lingering far behind the inflation curve.
"If there's an easier way to Buy Gold, I've not found it," says one BullionVault user. Find out why, and start with a free gram of gold in Zurich now...