Gold News

Why Emerging Markets Are Stagnating

...and why gold investment could rise everywhere as a result...

JAYANT BHANDARI has been an Asia-based institutional investor adviser for the last three years.

Prior to that he worked for six years with US Global Investors in the United States, a boutique natural resource investment firm, and for one year with Casey Research.

Now an independent investment adviser, Jayant Bhandari now sees gold demand rising across the world, as the emerging markets' chronic stagnation hits political turmoil, as he explains in this interview with The Gold Report...

The Gold Report: So far in 2016, Saudi Arabia has severed diplomatic ties with Iran over a religious dispute, and several Saudi allies have followed suit. Meanwhile, China's major stock exchanges started the year with a selloff, prompting the Chinese government to inject $20 billion into the system to help stabilize it. Which situation is likely to have a greater impact on the gold price?

Jayant Bhandari: It's not only a problem in the Middle East. The problem is in Africa. The problem is in South America. The problem is in Central and Southeast Asia. There is a huge amount of political turmoil in these areas. The reality is that most of the countries outside the West, with the exception of China and some smaller city-states, look very unstable. This will contribute to gold chasing by the populations in these countries because the economies are stagnant in all these countries except China and some city-states.

TGR: If there is global instability, don't rough waters threaten to sink all boats, even gold?

Jayant Bhandari: These are not sinking ships, these are ships that are stagnating. The economies in these countries are stagnating, and some of the countries are politically unstable. In all these cases, people buy gold. Historically, most of the gold purchasing has happened in the Middle East and the Indian subcontinent. These countries have negative-yielding economies, which means that investing in manufacturing or investing in infrastructure does not provide investors with a profit in these countries. Contrary to popular myth perpetuated by the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund, it is not the lack of capital that keeps poor countries poor, but their utter failure to productively deploy the capital.

For the last 30 years, imported technology from the West allowed these economies to grow very quickly. But the people in these countries haven't changed their cultures, which continues to be tribal and irrational. I am from India and the country completely refuses to change its ways of thinking. It benefitted from the low-hanging fruit that came with technology from the West, but the low-hanging fruit is gone.

TGR: What role do you expect India's stagnating economy to play in terms of gold demand in 2016 and beyond?

Jayant Bhandari: Indians are already buying increased amounts of gold. The reason is that the Indian stock market is going nowhere. When you adjust for inflation, which is typically 8-10% every year, investments do not provide you with any return, often negative returns. That's when investors start buying gold and property. The West continues to believe India will be the next China. I guarantee you that India is not the next China. Worse, I'm increasingly scared about India, as it has taken the path of fanaticism, in religion and in nationalistic feelings, both based on arrogance and dogma rather than on principles.

TGR: In different blog posts you've written that China's economic growth will continue for the foreseeable future. What are you seeing that most economists are not seeing when it comes to China?

Jayant Bhandari: The Chinese economy is still growing at between 6-7%. Economists like to say that China is slowing. That's erroneous. China is not slowing; Chinese growth is slowing. These things are different. Chinese growth is falling, which has to happen for a country that has grown at such an enormous pace for 20-30 years. I see nothing wrong with that. At 6-7%, China's economy is growing faster than most economies.

TGR: What do you make of China's recent stock market weakness?

Jayant Bhandari: It's difficult to understand what is happening with the day-to-day stock trading in any country, but the reality is that China continues to grow. I am very optimistic about China. The Chinese have among the highest IQs in the world and have consistently proven it. I don't waver with the day-to-day changes in the stock market. It's an emerging economy. China has had similar kinds of crashes in the past, and it has re-emerged from those crashes. It pays to remember that the stock market does not necessarily tell you about the underlying economy – the US stock market has done extremely well since the beginning of 2009, but its economy hasn't.

TGR: Are there other geopolitical events gold investors should be tracking?

Jayant Bhandari: The biggest thing that gold investors should pay attention to is not inflation or deflation – it's negative-yielding economies. This is the reason why people in the Indian subcontinent and Middle East have bought gold in the past. Most economies in countries outside the West are starting to stagnate. Interestingly, the same is increasingly visible in the West.

In Europe many sovereign bonds trade at negative yields, which means that there is an increased acceptance in Western countries toward becoming negative-yielding economies. Similarly, US publicly listed companies are sitting on trillions of Dollars of cash, earning negative real interest. That pretty much means that all economies are becoming stagnant. One of the biggest reasons is that democracies have placed people who don't understand economics in charge of economies. That is exactly when people buy a lot of gold and property because they have no better places to keep their money. Both land and gold offer you zero yields, and hence better than negative yields. This means that the stars are aligned for gold to go up. But what has to happen does not necessarily happen right away.

TGR: Do you think the US Federal Reserve made the right move when it made the 25-basis point interest rate increase in December 2015 and set guidance at 1.6% rates by the end of 2016?

Jayant Bhandari: The Fed did not increase interest rates enough. Savers get penalized when they get a 0% interest rate. This is morally discouraging for a society. Low interest rates create a boom-and-bust scenario, which means that a lot of malinvestments are taking place. But that does not mean that the Fed will further increase interest rates. I think the Fed will reduce interest rates again, for it is mostly run by people who have no real-life experience and hence they lack an understanding of complexity and unpredictability of life. They are mostly driven by political expediency.

TGR: Can the US inflate its way out of this?

Jayant Bhandari: There is not a chance. America has become a welfare state, which requires it to continue to print money. It might take a step back once in a while, but the movement eventually will be in the direction of increased money printing, increased inflation, increased regulation and increased oppression of entrepreneurs. The way our rulers think, they will do exactly more of what created the original problem. The average voter will go along, for he only worries about the seen, not the unseen, long-term consequences.

TGR: Historically, January tends to be a strong market for junior gold equities. How did tax-loss selling position the sector for what's happening now? Are we going to see a rebound or more of the same?

Jayant Bhandari: You will see an elastic rebound.

This year should be a very good year for the good companies in the junior mining sector after we saw a bifurcation occur in 2015. Some 70 to 80% of companies that have no value have continued to fall and will continue to fall, but the good companies have found a foothold and have made gains over the last year. Those companies will continue to increase in value as they raise money and move in the right direction. So I'm very optimistic about selective companies within the junior mining sector.

TGR: What are the key elements of a good junior mining company?

Jayant Bhandari: The biggest thing is the management. The quality of management is always key because if the management is not good, that will destroy value. It's hard to believe, but a lot of junior mining CEOs are financially illiterate. A lot of them live a lifestyle using the company's treasury.

TGR: As a long-time investor in the junior gold equity space, how are you approaching the market given the current economic backdrop?

Jayant Bhandari: I'm very optimistic about gold as a commodity. There are many companies that offer good value. I want to make money with the least amount of risk. Some people say that with risks come rewards. I don't think that is necessarily true. I'm looking to maximize my rewards for the least amount of risk. Today, the way the market is, I seek opportunities with arbitrage upside because that's free upside. Arbitrage opportunities offer you one of the safest and high reward opportunities in this market.

TGR: What is the one message you want to convey to investors at this moment in history?

Jayant Bhandari: The world has become quite unstable and governments have too much control over our savings and net worth. They already take away about half of what we produce, in a plethora of taxes. Despite this they are forever in deficits. It is important for investors to internationalize their wealth. It is important for them to take a part of their wealth outside the formal system to protect it from what might happen in the future. One way to do that is to invest in physical gold. What happened in Cyprus will happen in other countries. It's only a matter of time. Your accounts will get frozen. Your money will be expropriated by your government. It pays to prepare yourself for this eventuality.

TGR: Thank you for your insights, Jayant.

The Gold Report is a unique, free site featuring summaries of articles from major publications, specific recommendations from top worldwide analysts and portfolio managers covering gold stocks, and a directory, with samples, of precious metals newsletters. 

See the full archive of Gold Report articles.

Please Note: All articles published here are to inform your thinking, not lead it. Only you can decide the best place for your money, and any decision you make will put your money at risk. Information or data included here may have already been overtaken by events – and must be verified elsewhere – should you choose to act on it. Please review our Terms & Conditions for accessing Gold News.

Follow Us

Facebook Youtube Twitter LinkedIn



Market Fundamentals