Gold News

The rules, 2007

The Japanese Yen is now a key driver of both the Dow Jones and gold...

JESSE LIVERMORE is widely regarded as one of the greatest stock market operators of all-time. He considered himself a humble student of the market right up until his final day in 1940.

   "I study the market, because it's my business to trade," he once remarked. "In the forty years which I have devoted to making speculation a successful business venture, I am still discovering new rules to apply to that business.

   "Experience has taught me the way a market behaves is an excellent guide for an operator to follow. Observation gives you the best tips of all, and the behavior of a certain market is all you need at times. You observe, and then experience shows you how to profit by variations from the usual – that is to say, from the probable."

Had Livermore been operating in today's markets, he might have found it intriguing that the direction of the Japanese Yen would become a key driver of the Dow Jones Industrials. Traditional indicators such as the health of the US economy, company earnings, cash flow, and future sales forecasts are all taking a backseat to forecasting the direction of the heavily manipulated Japanese Yen in the foreign exchange market, in order to predict the Dow Jones Industrials.

The infamous "Yen carry" trade, which involves borrowing in Japanese Yen at less than 1% to invest in riskier assets like commodities and stocks, has mushroomed to an estimated $500 billion to $800 billion in size. It's made the Bank of Japan the world's top central banker, and the US Treasury and the Federal Reserve are key collaborators with Tokyo in guiding the Dollar/Yen and the Dow Jones Industrials.

Someday, the Dow Industrials' obsession with the Dollar/Yen exchange rate will fade into oblivion. But for now, it's the endless flow of cheap capital from Tokyo that is pumping up the DJI Index to record highs, at a time when the US economy is slowing towards zero percent growth, and S&P 500 earnings growth is expected to slow to between 6-8% year-on-year in Q1, after four-and-a-half years of straight double-digit profit gains.

The DJI's 416-point plunge on February 27th was the seventh largest daily point loss in history. Ignited by a sudden plunge in the US Dollar from ¥120.75 to ¥118, it is now just a fading memory. Five weeks later, the DJI is once again riding high, recouping most of its panic stricken losses from the Feb 27th to March 13th shakeout.

That makes it the shortest and shallowest correction from a record high in history.

Instead, it was the US Dollar's recovery from a low of ¥115.25 on March 5th to ¥119.25 on April 10th that revived bullish sentiment on Wall Street. Higher stock prices at a time of slowing earnings growth can raise S&P price/earnings ratios to dangerously high levels. But it's the Bank of Japan's 0.50% overnight loan rate – plus the Fed's purchases of long-dated bonds in the Treasury market – that are the primary obsession of US and global stock market operators these days.

US data wonks prop up the Dollar

The "Yen carry" trade continues to appear a "risk-free" trade, with both the Japanese Ministry of Finance and the US Treasury working for a stronger Dollar against the Yen. However, the "Yen carry" trade did blow-up on February 27th, thanks to unexpected meltdowns in the share prices of US sub-prime lenders.

Top US mortgage lender Countrywide Financial (CFC.N) extended its recent losses to $32.50 per share on April 2nd, after top sub-prime lender New Century Financial filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy.

The demise of New Century came less than two months after it had first disclosed problems with delinquent and defaulted loans. It stopped making loans last month, after having made nearly $60 billion in 2006.

"Sub-prime woes are not a small issue," said the 81-year-old former Fed kingpin 'Easy' Al Greenspan on March 16th. "Much of the strength in consumer spending over the past five years could be traced to capital gains, both realized and unrealized, on surging housing prices."

"If home prices keep falling, there could be more of an impact on the broader US economy's momentum," Greenspan warned. But the US Plunge Protection Team (aka the President's Working Group of Financial Markets) has been working overtime with Japan's Ministry of Finance to repair the damage to global stock markets. They've bee downplaying the risks to the US economy from the sub-prime loan meltdown, and pursuing policies to keep the Yen weak.

After "closely tracking" the slide of CFC.N in February and March, the Dollar/Yen exchange rate began to diverge from CFC.N in April, as currency traders bet on a rosy US employment report on April 6th.

Labor Department apparatchniks have a history of tinkering with US employment reports. Last Aug., Labor revised an original 128,000 increase in payrolls into a gain of 230,000 jobs. Sept.'s 51,000 increase was revised upwards to a 148,000 gain. Last Nov., Labor apparatchniks raised a lot of eyebrows when their fuzzy math produced an extra 810,000 jobs from Apr. 2005 through Mar. '06 – all with the simple stroke of a pen.

So traders bet correctly when Labor reported a "stronger-than-expected" 180,000 new jobs for Mar. this year. The jobless rate slipped to 4.4%, a six-year low, implying the US economy remains resilient despite a slowdown in housing.

Labor went two steps further and revised upward the estimate for jobs created in Jan. and Feb. by 16,000 each month to 162,000 and 113,000 respectively.

Still, the most glaring irregularity in Labor's latest employment report was a 56,000 increase in construction jobs to a near record 7.7 million workers. That offset a decline of 61,000 in Feb. One might have suspected that the sizeable loss of construction jobs in Feb. was the beginning of a trend, and not a one-time fluke, given the 33% slide in housing starts since January 2006.

Overall, construction jobs have shown no net growth since peaking in Sept. '06. Until then, the housing industry was the key engine of job growth in the United States, and had accounted for more than half of private payroll jobs created since 2001.

But Labor's fuzzy math is not subject to the same audits or accounting standards as all those home-builder's earning reports due in the weeks ahead. And Labor's claim that US construction employment remains unchanged from a year ago doesn't jive with industry reports.

Luxury-home builder Toll Brothers (TOL.N) said its first-quarter profit dropped 67% from a year ago. Lennar (LEN.N), the No.3 home builder, posted a 73.4% plunge in profit, saying the industry's spring selling season has failed to bloom and its outlook for the rest of 2007 does not look bright.

"While some markets are performing better than others, the typically stronger spring selling season has not yet materialized," said Stuart Miller, Lennar's CEO.

"These soft market conditions have been exacerbated by the well-publicized problems in the sub-prime lending market," he said. So it defies all logic that hemorrhaging US home builders are retaining idle workers and not initiating layoffs, as Labor's stats suggest.

Many bond traders do not trust Labor's fuzzy math, and instead rely on private surveys, such as the NAPM report on manufacturing employment. It showed a contraction in factory jobs in Mar., matching Labor's claim of a 16,000 job loss. However, the ISM index on service sector employment stood at 50.8 last month, compared with Dec.'s 53.1, and Aug. 2005's 59.9, when US home builder share prices topped out ahead of their 50% year-long slide.

Together, the private surveys show stagnant to contracting US jobs growth. The rising US Dollar doesn't fit.

Bank of Japan keeps its powder dry

The Bank of Japan (BOJ) sat tight on monetary policy on April 10th, reluctant to follow up on its February interest-rate hike due to fear of another unwinding of the "Yen carry" trade.

That kept the overnight call rate target at 0.50% for the second month in a row – and in a unanimous vote. It is likely to lead to a clash with European finance ministers at the April 13th G7 meeting in Washington.

The BOJ said year-on-year changes in consumer prices are moving around zero percent and are likely to stay there for the near term, reflecting recent falls in crude oil prices. That's led to expectations the BOJ will keep its powder dry at 0.50% until the July-September quarter or possibly longer.

But clearly, with Japan's economy expanding at a 5.5% annualized rate in Q4, the BoJ's overnight loan rate of 0.50% is far out of alignment with the rest of the world, and creating bubbles worldwide. BOJ hawk Atsushi Mizuno warned on Feb 28th:

"The side effects of keeping low interest rates regardless of economic conditions could prompt Yen weakness and may increase protectionism among Japan's trading partners. It could also cause distortions in global asset prices by speeding up capital outflows from Japan."

Tokyo's financial warlords are manipulating the inflation data, and claim that Japan is still suffering from deflation. That's despite an 86% surge in the Dow Jones Commodity Price Index versus the Yen from five years ago.

Last week, Tokyo said consumer prices were -0.2% lower in Feb. from a year earlier, even while the rest of the world is grappling with inflation (albeit according to heavily sedated government statistics).

It might only be a matter of time until the "Yen carry" trade lifts commodity prices to new record highs in Japan. BOJ deputy Toshiro Muto said on April 4th that inflationary pressures will likely increase in the future and the central bank will gradually nudge up interest rates.

"As we have said before, we have no predetermined schedule for future policy changes in mind," he said.

But the ruling LDP party, led by the radical inflationist Shinzo Abe, is staunchly opposed to rate hikes. He wants to keep Japan's debt payments low.

As of March 31st, Japan's national debt was $6.7 trillion, and the annual interest expense totaled $177 billion. A one per cent increase in 10-year bond yields would push up Tokyo's debt-servicing costs by 1.6 trillion Yen ($13.6 billion), the Ministry of Finance has estimated.

Debt-servicing costs already eat up about a quarter of spending in the annual budget. So without enormous political pressure from Europe, Tokyo won't budge on interest rates.

Euro/Yen carry traders wreak havoc on ECB

Because of Tokyo's refusal to raise Yen interest rates – supported by the US Treasury – European central bankers find themselves in a dilemma. The Euro M3 money supply is exploding at a 10% annual growth rate. It requires a tighter ECB money policy to head-off inflationary pressures in the Eurozone economy. Yet unilateral ECB rate hikes that are not matched by the BoJ could send the "Euro /yen" rate much higher.

European finance ministers are staunchly opposed to Tokyo's cheap Yen policy. They drew a line in the sand for the Euro at ¥160 at the Essen G7 meeting. European finance ministers view Tokyo's weak Yen policy as a clandestine attempt to help Japanese exporters grab market share around the globe at the expense of European exporters.

On March 20th, EU finance chief Jean-Claude Juncker said the Japanese Yen must reflect the fundamentals of the Japanese economy. "The fact that the Bank of Japan didn't raise interest rates hardly surprises me," he said after the BOJ left its overnight call rate target at 0.50% on March 20th.

"I think that some people in Europe and elsewhere had got their hopes up after the recent interest rate rise. We stick to the message that we sent at the Essen G7 meeting.

"We think that Japanese growth is without doubt picking up. We think that the exchange rate must reflect the fundamental facts of the Japanese economy. Our Japanese friends know that. And we are watching them," Juncker warned.

But without higher Japanese interest rates, European "jawboning" is losing its potency. And it won't be the first time that Tokyo has broken a pledge to cooperate with the G7 on foreign currency issues.

On 20th Sept. 2003, the G7 finance ministers called for Japan to reduce its sales of the Yen after it had already sold an unprecedented ¥9 trillion (some $76.8 billion) from Jan. through July trying to support the US Dollar. But Tokyo resumed massive Yen sales within a few weeks, dumping ¥26 trillion on the market from Nov. 2003 through Mar. 2004 to prevent the Dollar from tumbling to ¥100.

The Euro/Yen carry trade is starting to turn the ECB's monetary policy upside down. The Euro's recovery from ¥151 on March 5th to a record high of ¥160 on April 10th enabled gold to rebound from a low of €480 to €506 per ounce.

At the same time, Germany's 10-year bund yield briefly rose to a three-and-half-year high of 4.15%, reflecting higher gold prices. European traders can borrow Yen at roughly 1% and use it to buy gold, while pocketing the Euro's gains against the Yen. ECB policy doesn't come into it.

The Euro's strong recovery to a record high of ¥160 is linked to ideas that the European Central Bank will hike its repo lending rate by 50 basis points in the months ahead, and that hike won't be matched by the Bank of Japan. Thus, in a strange twist of logic, signals of a tighter ECB money policy are actually elevating European gold prices because of the distorting impact of the Euro/Yen carry trade.

Gold would be about 3% higher if the ECB hadn't stepped up its sales in March. It dumped 45.5 tons into the gold market, yet gold still managed to climb against the Euro last month. In Sept. 2006, when the ECB dumped 50 tons of gold in the spot market and sold 100 tons in the forward market, gold plummeted by €40 to €440 per ounce. And in May 2006, when the ECB dumped 75 tons, gold plunged €120 per ounce to €430.

What's fascinating about the Euro/Yen exchange rate these days, is that tiny moves in interest-rate differentials between Europe and Japan are leading to explosive moves in the cross rate. The Euro's recovery from ¥151 to as high as ¥160 this week was accompanied by a mere 16 basis point increase in the Euro Libor rate over the Yen Libor rate.

If the ECB has to lift its repo rate by at least 50 basis points to control the M3 money supply, without a similar increase by the Bank of Japan, then the Euro/Yen rate could soar. In a strange twist, that would lift gold prices and send German bund yields much higher – just the opposite of what the ECB would like to accomplish.

Shanghai Bubble Expands to Record Proportions

Jesse Livermore would have been intrigued by the Shanghai red chip market, which is reminiscent of the middle stages of the Nasdaq 1998-99 bubble. Left unchecked, the world is witnessing one of the greatest stock market rallies in history, ranking alongside Japan's Nikkei 225 of 1986-90 and the Russian Trading System Index of the last decade.

The Shanghai Composite Index is now recording fresh record highs. It has gained 25% since its widely reported 9% dive on February 27th.

All lip service and tightening measures by Chinese authorities to keep Shanghai red chips from surging higher haven't turned back the Asian stampede. It's highly doubtful that Livermore, who made $100 million during the 1929 stock market crash, would try to pick a top or start short-selling this market.

Foreign money is flooding into China, with its trade surplus doubling to $46.4 billion in the first quarter. On April 6th, the Chinese central bank hiked bank reserve ratios by 0.5% to 10.5%, ordering lenders to set aside more money in reserve for the sixth time in less than a year, removing about 170 billion yuan from the banking system.

But unless the required reserve ratio is raised to more than 13%, which isn't likely, all efforts by the People's Bank of China (PBoC) to slow explosive loan growth and the money supply are just cosmetic overtures. China's banks still have an average excess reserve deposit ratio of 3%, and its largest banks have the highest capital ratios, providing them with a sizeable cushion when they're ordered to increase reserves.

M2, China's broadest measure of money supply, expanded at an annual 17.8% clip in Feb. Outstanding bank loans climbed 17.2%. New lending was 981 billion yuan for the first two months combined, almost a third of the total for all of 2006. Factory output in Jan. and Feb. combined grew 18.5% from a year earlier, blowing past the 16.2% rise logged in the first two months of 2006.

The PBoC drained 655 billion yuan from the banking system in March with T-bill sales, and guided the widely watched 7-day repo rate from as low as 1.5% in mid-March to 2% today. In fact, the Chinese central bank can now issue one-year Yuan T-bills at 3% in Shanghai – soaking up excess cash from the economy – and then deposit the funds in US one-year bills at 5.25%.

Thus, the PBoC has become the world's largest "Yuan carry" trader.

But the 7-day repo rate remains far below the 2.7% consumer price inflation rate, indicating that China is still pursuing a super-easy money policy. Beijing has only allowed the Yuan to appreciate by 1% so far this year, by printing enormous amounts of Yuan to keep its currency artificially low.

Seeking to stay ahead of monetary inflation, Chinese investors are bidding up the red-chip stocks, and turnover in Shanghai A shares ballooned to a record 152.3 billion yuan ($19.7 billion) on April 10th. Baoshan Iron and Steel (600019.SS), China's top steel maker, said it expects to post a 150% jump in 2007 first-quarter net profit from a year earlier, boosted by higher steel prices. BaoSteel plans to raise its steel prices by 5% to 7% in the second quarter.

Tight supply and strong demand from Chinese steel mills, the largest consumers of nickel, have lifted nickel prices into the stratosphere, hitting a new record high of $50,000 per ton, up from $15,000 just one year ago.

China produced 23.1% more crude steel in the first two months of this year, or 74.25 million tons. That's after output grew 19.7% in 2006 to 422.7 million tons. China steel mills will become increasingly dependent on imports of lower-cost iron ore, which could rise by 60 million tons this year.

Livermore used to say there is nothing new under the sun in the stock market. But the "Yen carry" trade is turning some long held fundamental beliefs about investing upside down. The Shanghai bubble has been seen before in different clothing, and it's possible that it might never come back down to earth, much like the Brazilian and Russian stock markets.

To keep in touch with the latest news and analysis of these markets and more, subscribe to the Global Money Trends newsletter.

GARY DORSCH is editor of the Global Money Trends newsletter. He worked as chief financial futures analyst for three clearing firms on the trading floor of the Chicago Mercantile Exchange before moving to the US and foreign equities trading desk of Charles Schwab and Co.

There he traded across 45 different exchanges, including Australia, Canada, Japan, Hong Kong, the Eurozone, London, Toronto, South Africa, Mexico and New Zealand. With extensive experience of forex, US high grade and corporate junk bonds, foreign government bonds, gold stocks, ADRs, a wide range of US equities and options as well as Canadian oil trusts, he wrote from 2000 to Sept. '05 a weekly newsletter, Foreign Currency Trends, for Charles Schwab's Global Investment department.

See the full archive of Gary Dorsch.


Please Note: All articles published here are to inform your thinking, not lead it. Only you can decide the best place for your money, and any decision you make will put your money at risk. Information or data included here may have already been overtaken by events – and must be verified elsewhere – should you choose to act on it. Please review our Terms & Conditions for accessing Gold News.

Follow Us

Facebook Youtube Twitter LinkedIn



Market Fundamentals