We use cookies (including third-party cookies such as Google) to remember your site preferences and to help us understand how visitors use our sites so we can improve them. To learn more, please see our privacy policy and our cookie policy.

To agree to our use of cookies, click 'Accept' or choose 'Options' to set your preferences by cookie type.

Options Accept
BullionVault

CHARTS

  • English
  • Deutsch
  • Español
  • Français
  • Italiano
  • Polski
  • 日本語
  • 简体中文
  • 繁體中文
  • Daily audit
  • Help
  • Contact
  • Deposit
  • Login
  • Open account
  • ABOUT US
    • About BullionVault
    • In the press
    • Reviews
    BUY/SELL BULLION
    • Vaulted gold & silver
    • -Live order board
    • -Daily Price
    • Coins for delivery (UK)
    INVESTMENT GUIDE
    • Guide to gold
    • -How to buy gold
    • -Gold investment
    • -Gold investment plan
    • -Investment insurance
    • -Compare asset performance
    • Guide to silver
    • -How to buy silver
    • Guide to platinum
    • -How to buy platinum
    GOLD NEWS
    • Gold news front page
    • -Gold price news
    • -Opinion & analysis
    • -Market fundamentals
    • -Gold/Silver Investor Index
    • -Infographics
    CHARTS
    • Gold price
    • Silver price
    • Platinum price
    • Price alerts
  • Login
  • Open account
  • BUY/SELL BULLION
  • Vaulted gold & silver
    • ⤷
    • Live order board
    • Daily Price
  • Coins for delivery (UK)
  • INVESTMENT GUIDE
  • Guide to gold
    • ⤷
    • How to buy gold
    • Gold investment
    • Gold investment plan
    • Investment insurance
    • Compare asset performance
  • Guide to silver
    • ⤷
    • How to buy silver
  • Guide to platinum
    • ⤷
    • How to buy platinum
  • GOLD NEWS
  • Gold news front page
    • ⤷
    • Gold price news
    • Opinion & analysis
    • Market fundamentals
    • Gold/Silver Investor Index
    • Infographics
  • CHARTS
  • Gold price
  • Silver price
  • Platinum price
  • Price alerts
  • ABOUT US
  • About BullionVault
  • In the press
  • Reviews
  • Help
  • Contact
  • Daily audit
    • English
    • Deutsch
    • Español
    • Français
    • Italiano
    • Polski
    • 日本語
    • 简体中文
    • 繁體中文

Gold News

Live support

NEED HELP? ASK US NOW

Search form

Gold News front page

Gold Price News

Gold Priced Like Covid Never Happened as Powell 'Fails to Rescue' Stocks from Bond Slump

More...

Gold Investing In Depth

Learn about gold bullion bars

Learn about gold bullion coins (and costs)

Gold investment: Why & how?

Gold Investment Analysis

  • Latest Gold Investor Index
  • Diversification: Gold as investment insurance
  • 40-year Asset Performance Comparison Table

Gold Articles

Opinion & Analysis

Gold Price News

Investment News

Gold in History

Gold Books

Gold Investor Index

Gold Infographics

Archive

  • March 2021 (5)
  • February 2021 (23)
  • January 2021 (25)
  • December 2020 (24)
  • November 2020 (23)
More...

List of authors

Cat Meets Pigeons in London Fix Regulation

Friday, 1/17/2014 12:37
Gold Fix loses Deutsche Bank within 18 hours of regulator BaFin speech. Coincidence...?
 
The LONDON GOLD FIX is going to get smaller, and potentially less liquid, with news that Deutsche Bank is quitting, writes Adrian Ash at BullionVault.
 
Lower liquidity is the opposite of what Germany's financial regulator BaFin said only last night it wants to foster. But the two events would seem far from unrelated.
 
You've heard of Deutsche no doubt. Big investment and retail bank, based in Germany (and so regulated primarily by BaFin, the German financial authority), it is also a market-making member of the London Bullion Market Association. It guarantees to quote bid/offers in gold and silver throughout the day.
 
Deutsche Bank is also a member of the London Gold Fixing and London Silver Fixing companies. Entirely independent of the LBMA, these limited businesses exist for the sole purpose of reaching and reporting the Fix price each day.
 
The Fix is a shapshot of where the London price is sitting at a certain time (10.30am and 3pm gold, midday silver). Because London remains the centre of bullion dealing worldwide, it acts as THE global benchmark.
 
Jewelers use the London Fix to price their product. Central banks use it to value their hoards. Investment funds use it to track gold's performance (once up, now down). Mining companies use the Fix to sell their product to the wholesale market, once refined into large, Good Delivery bars. Miners also use the benchmark to raise finance through those same bullion banks, referencing far-distant Fixes as the settlement price for forward contracts.
 
How is each Fix achieved each day? It is created in parallel to the "spot" market, but is pretty much where spot prices trade at the moment that the Fix is set. In spot, each buyer and seller meets directly (just as you can on BullionVault), setting price as they choose in individual deals, rather than market-wide. Whereas the Fix sees a small group of big banks (5 in gold, 3 in silver...or now 4 and 2) bring their client orders for that event to the table.
 
Together, they then seek a single market-wide price which will clear the greatest volume of those client requests. (Again, Bullionvault users can trade at that daily price point too if they wish.)
 
So unlike the headline scandals in Libor and Euribor interest rates, the London gold and silver Fixes are built from "actual transactions in liquid markets." That's according to Dr.Elke König, president of German financial regulators BaFin, in a speech in Frankfurt last night.
 
So far, so good for the London Fix, then.
 
Indeed, "Benchmarks should be as far as possible based on real transactions," König said, contrasting the currency and precious metals benchmarks with those discredited Libor and Euribor interest rates, which are merely "estimates of the banks", not real prices created by real supply and demand.
 
But there was more from the BaFin chief. And while it's perhaps coincidence that within 18 hours of her speech, Deutsche Bank said it's quitting the Fix (and so far without a full press release online), Dr.König was plain about where the German financial regulator sees the future for financial benchmarks like the London gold and silver Fixes.
"Expert assessments of price should be seen as valid/legitimate, but only if they can be proved. At present, the Commission [ie, regulators like BaFin] accept self-monitoring by the market. But the relevant data should be clearly documented and checked by an independent, private control body."
What's more, "In Brussels, new market abuse regulations are now being prepared. Manipulation of benchmarks should become a crime."
 
The London Fixes, of course, happen in the UK – and London stands accused by its European (and US) partners of allowing the financial crisis to build and explode through too much "light touch" and not enough "central control". So the UK regulator, the Financial Conduct Authority, has already started looking into the London Gold Fix. Word is, the FCA has an observer there, just as it has for some time on the management committee of the much wider London Bullion Market Association.
 
Like the spot market, the Fix is also done away from any formal, centralized trading exchange. Which is just how the free-market likes it. Willing seller to willing buyer, with each judging the other's credit-worthiness for themselves against the standard two-day settlement terms. This keeps everyone on their toes, rather than letting "regulatory oversight" lull everyone into thinking they're safe because a bureaucracy says so.
 
But as the financial crisis recedes, regulation is enjoying a bigger bull market than US biotech stocks. And "market transparency and market control are only possible if the countless flows of business are centralized," reckons BaFin's König. "One would therefore want these benchmarks to move as far as possible onto a transparent and directly or indirectly state-supervised trading exchange."
 
To sum up then: Criminalization, loss of client (or at least trade-flow) privacy, and transfer to a centralized "government-supervised" exchange.
 
If it is coincidence that Deutsche said it's quitting the Fix this morning, straight after BaFin's speech, it would be rare timing indeed.
 
Look, we hold no candle for the bullion banks, let alone their investment banking parents. But we have shown before how the London Fix works, why it's useful, and how it achieves a price through freely-decided buying and selling.
 
Regulatory rumour and now comment today look directly responsible for removing one-fifth of the Gold Fix's client-base, and one-third of silver's. (Deutsche's loss is the first change to Fix line-up since N.M.Rothchild Bank quit in 2004, just as gold's two-decade bear market was really switching into a powerful uptrend.) That's hardly good for the liquidity which BaFin itself says is vital to a sound benchmark.
 
More broadly, the loss of "prop trading" by banks in precious, commodities and other markets (locked out by the rules of the US Dodd-Frank Act in the main) also threatens to cause a loss of liquidity in regular daily trade as well. Deutsche and other banks have already shrunk much of their other commodity business. Deutsche this week also suspended a handful of currency traders from its New York office, now under investigation for allegations of manipulating its 15% share of the FX market, alongside other "cartel" players. No doubt banks trading their own money (or rather, their shareholders' funds) is a risky business. And no doubt reported benchmarks, rather than those created by client order flow across different firms, open the door to malfeasance. So if the banks are to get state guarantees, bailing them out when they hit trouble, then that risk should be eliminated to save taxpayers subsidizing reckless trading and the fat bonuses which can follow manipulation.
 
The alternative (can you imagine!) would be to remove that state guarantee, letting the banks trade as they wish and go to the wall when they fail, while clients take responsibility for judging market prices as they choose. We can but dream, right? Instead however, and should this trend continue, expect thinner trade long-term, punctuated by spikes on heavy volume when big investment positions or deals are done.
 
All in a day's work for regulation. State-guaranteed banks and free markets cannot go together.
  • Reddit logo
  • Facebook logo
  • Twitter logo
  • Google logo
  • Yahoo logo
  • LinkedIn logo
  • Digg logo
  • StumbleUpon logo
  • Technorati logo

Adrian Ash is director of research at BullionVault, the physical gold and silver market for private investors online. Formerly head of editorial at London's top publisher of private-investment advice, he was City correspondent for The Daily Reckoning from 2003 to 2008, and is now a regular contributor to many leading analysis sites including Forbes and a regular guest on BBC national and international radio and television news. Adrian's views on the gold market have been sought by the Financial Times and Economist magazine in London; CNBC, Bloomberg and TheStreet.com in New York; Germany's Der Stern; Italy's Il Sole 24 Ore, and many other respected finance publications.

See the full archive of Adrian Ash articles on GoldNews.

Please Note: All articles published here are to inform your thinking, not lead it. Only you can decide the best place for your money, and any decision you make will put your money at risk. Information or data included here may have already been overtaken by events – and must be verified elsewhere – should you choose to act on it. Please review our Terms & Conditions for accessing Gold News.

Follow Us

Facebook Youtube Twitter LinkedIn

 

Mobile apps

 - live trading 24/7

 - buy & sell instantly

 - up-to-the-second charts

 

 

 

Daily news email
Go to 'communications settings' 

Get the latest daily gold price news free by email

Latest gold news by email

 

 

 

Gold Investor Index
2 March 2021

Silver Investor Index

Silver beats gold again

 

 

 

LBMA webinar
21 January 2021

LBMA

London gold trading

 

 

 

Bloomberg TV
1 February 2021

Bloomberg TV

r/silver-surge

 

 

 

ET Now
3 March 2021

Gold drop

Gold's big drop

 

 

 

  •  Email us

Market Fundamentals

  • Green Energy: Platinum Key to New 'Hydrogen Catapult'
  • 2021 Gold Price to Rise 11.5%: LBMA Forecast
  • 'Cut Bullion Duty to Cut Smuggling': India's Gold Industry
More...
  • Cost calculator
  • Cookies
  • Terms & conditions

©BullionVault Ltd 2005-

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube

Save your cookie preferences

We use cookies to remember your site preferences, record your referrer and improve the performance of our site. For more information, see our cookie policy.

Please select an option below and 'Save' your preferences.

Save

You can update your cookie preferences at any time from the 'Cookies' link in the footer.

Secure auto-logout warning

You have not been active for some time.

For your security you will be logged out in   minutes unless you take action.