The Insanity of Negative Rates

Get ready for more...

The GOOD FOLK at Absolute Return Partners have identified eight megatrends, long-term investment themes that they believe will define the world of the future, writes Tim Price on his The ThePriceofEverything blog.
   
Those themes are:

1. The end of the debt super-cycle;
2. The retirement of the baby-boomers;
3. The declining spending power of the middle classes;
4. The rise of the East;
5. Mean reversion of wealth-to-GDP;
6. Disruption;
7. Running out of fresh water;
8. Electrification of everything.

These are "secular trends, expected to fully develop over a five to ten year horizon and provide useful reference points for us when forming our views of where to dedicate our resources and, ultimately, where to allocate our clients' money."

They may not be properly investible theses as such, but we would add the following: the poisonous intensification of identity politics; the collapse of economic knowledge and respect for free markets; the dismal rise of unaccountable technocrats at our central banks; and the calamitous rise of the intrusive Big State and all the unintended financial and cultural consequences of its various interventions.

Putting to one side any caveats about succumbing to narrative fallacy, the Absolute Return Partners list implies two requisite actions on the part of concerned investors: moving capital away from those areas most jeopardised by these trends, and moving capital towards those areas most likely to benefit from these same trends.

The "end" of the debt super-cycle seems a clear example of the former. (Avoid bonds !) First, a quick historical recap. The following extract is from Investing Through the Looking Glass – a rational guide to irrational financial markets:

"The downfall of the Western financial system began during an episode of Bonanza. Speaking to the American nation on television on 15 August 1971, interrupting the popular Western series in the process, President Nixon announced that the US Dollar would 'temporarily' no longer be convertible into gold. (The temporary prohibition lasts to this day.)

"For nearly 30 years leading up to that announcement, a system known as Bretton Woods had fixed the value of foreign currencies to the US Dollar, and pegged the US Dollar itself to the price of gold, at an exchange rate of $35 per ounce. But by 1971, the US government was en route to bankruptcy, courtesy of a guns and butter economic policy initiated by the earlier President Lyndon Johnson, who had landed America with the costs not just of a Great Society welfare programme, but of the Vietnam War into the bargain.

"Foreign countries, not least the French, were queuing up to exchange their increasingly worthless Dollars for gold. The run on the US' gold reserves had begun.

"By removing its last links with gold, and slamming shut the window where currency could be exchanged for gold, Nixon was effectively devaluing the Dollar. But by removing any practical constraints to the printing of Dollars, Nixon also ushered in a period for the unrestrained creation of credit. If the US government was unable to balance its budget through tax revenues, it could simply print Dollars to its heart's content to make up the shortfall. And the US government has been no slouch when it comes to money printing ever since.

"By closing the gold window, the US government consciously removed the brake restraining the Fed from money creation without limit. The Fed was given the very tools that, if abused, would bring down the system. In the aftermath of the so-called Nixon Shock, governments and central banks around the world, with their own currencies no longer pegged to the Dollar, have enjoyed a similar privilege. 1971 marked the start of the world's biggest orgy of debt. It was a starting gun for what will ultimately prove an economic race to the bottom."

We are closer to that economic base today. Central bank policy increasingly resembles a desperate scraping of the bottom of the barrel. Mario Draghi is probably asking himself what's underneath the barrel.

We recently highlighted the economic insanity of negative interest rates – a state of affairs that already exists in the Eurozone, and which US monetary policy officials have threatened in the event of another lurch downwards by the US economy.

John Plender for the Financial Times ('Why 'Japanification' looms for the sluggish Euro zone') was not alone in drawing comparisons between the economic desperation that has overwhelmed the ECB and the malaise which so insidiously gripped post-bubble Japan:

"Confronted with slowing economic growth, uncertain politics and wobbly markets the European Central Bank reliably came to the rescue [this month] with new stimulus measures and a deferral of the start to any normalisation of interest rates. Yet, despite the soothing medicine, equity markets were initially unsettled."

With low growth and low inflation, says Plender, "It could be argued that the Eurozone has its own version of the 'Japanification' syndrome." It enjoys a big current account surplus, saving more than it invests.So it relies on the rest of the world for "demand stimulus".

Japan got here well before the rest of us, so it is only fair that it should now be finding its feet again. Abenomics has helped. And Japanese companies, for example, now have the healthiest balance sheets in the world.

But the Eurozone lacks Japan's social cohesion and, being a mongrel assemblage of disparate cultures, it lacks any ingrained natural willingness to "take one for the team".

We have long held the view that, with central bankers collectively having lost their minds and any relationship with reality, the smartest move in the game is likely to be "not to play". So other investors are welcome to "invest" in government bonds, especially those issued by colossal debtor countries. Since the ultimate outcome from the global debt predicament is predestined to be inflationary (regardless or perhaps even because of the shorter term deflationary outlook), it makes all the sense in the world to favour sensibly priced real assets over ridiculously priced nominal ones.

Items 3) and 4) on Absolute Return Partners' list amount to two sides of the same coin. Middle and especially working class populations in the West are already suffering from declining spending power thanks to the inflationary, unproductive Big State policies of their governments. But on the other side of the world, the opposite is true.

The OECD forecasts that the Asian middle class population, currently a little over 500 million, will reach 3 billion people by 2030. This will equate to the greatest creation of wealth in human history. And all thanks to free markets and capitalism, not despite them.

Things have reached a strange place in market history when the Chinese Communist Party does more for wealth creation than politicians in the West.