Gold News

Gold vs. Stocks: Worst Yet to Come

The US just reached a tipping point in its new Greater Depression...

DOUG CASEY, chairman of Casey Research LLC, has spent significant time in more than 170 different countries so far in his lifetime, living in 12 of them (currently New Zealand and Argentina) to help identify the best investment opportunities he can find, says the Gold Report.

A guest of David Letterman, Larry King, Merv Griffin, Charlie Rose, Phil Donahue, Regis Philbin and Maury Povich, the author of Crisis Investing has been the topic of numerous features in periodicals such as Time, Forbes, People, US, Barron's and the Washington Post – not to mention countless articles he's written for his own various websites, publications and subscribers.

Now both Gold Bullion and crude oil lead the line-up of power players that Doug Casey thinks investors can count on as the world slips deeper and deeper into what he calls the "Greater Depression".

The Gold Report caught up with the peripatetic author, publisher and professional international investor between polo matches in New Zealand...

The Gold Report: You've been discussing what you're calling "crisis and opportunity", and in fact have a summit by that same name coming up in Las Vegas next month. Could you give us a high-level overview of what you foresee?

Doug Casey: We've definitely entered what I describe as the Greater Depression. It's not coming; it's here. It's going to get much, much worse as far as I'm concerned and unfortunately, it's going to last a long time. It doesn't have to last a long time, but the root cause is government intervention in the economy and everything they're doing now is not just the wrong thing, it's the opposite of what they should be doing. It's almost perverse.

The distortions and misallocations of capital and the uneconomic patterns of production and consumption that have been going on for over a generation need to be liquidated and changed, but everything the government's doing is trying to maintain these patterns. So it's going to be horrible. In addition, the government is necessarily directing more power toward itself with all of its actions. If I were you, I'd rig for stormy running for a good long time.

TGR: By "a long time", do you mean a couple of years, a decade, or a generation?

Doug Casey: This is, in some ways, uncharted territory. Let me say that for the long run I'm very optimistic. Why? Two things act as the mainsprings of progress.

Number one is technology and that's going to keep advancing, so that's very good. Second is capital and savings. Individuals will solve their own problems and, therefore, they will stop consuming more than they produce, which is what they've been doing for years, and they'll again start producing more than they consume. The difference is savings; that builds capital.

So technology and capital are going to solve the depression. But the government can do all kinds of stupid things to make it worse. Look at the Soviet Union. They suffered a depression that lasted 70 years from its founding. Look at China. The whole reign of Mao was one long economic depression. That could certainly happen in the US, too, where the government misallocates capital in such a way that technology doesn't advance as it could and people can't build individual capital the way they would. I'm optimistic, but anything can happen.

TGR: But didn't China and the Soviet Union have governmental structures very different from those in Western Europe and the US, and those structures allowed for more intervention? Are you projecting that we might slip into an era where Western civilization will allow their government to run themselves like the Soviet Union and China did?

Doug Casey: It seems to be going in that direction. Of course, Europe is going to be hurt much worse than the US Europeans are much more heavily taxed and much more heavily regulated. The average European is much more reliant upon the state psychologically as well as economically. So it's all over for Europe and this doesn't even count the problems that they're going to have in the continuing war against Islam, which are much more serious for Europe than they are for the US.

So, no, Europe is fated to be nothing but a source of houseboys and maids for the Chinese in the next generation.

TGR: So do you think that societies in Western Europe – and even the US – will allow themselves to be governed in the same fashion as the Soviet Union and China were during their depressions?

Doug Casey: Oh, totally. I don't see why that would not be the case. Even Newsweek says we're all socialists now. That seems to be the reigning ideology. In addition, psychologically, the average American – just like the average European – looks to the government to solve things. This is very bad.

Most people are unaware that Homeland Security, which is one agency that should be abolished post-haste, is building a 400-acre campus in southeast Washington, D.C., where initially they're going to put 25,000 employees. That's as many as the Pentagon has – and with 400 acres, Homeland Security has a lot more room to grow.

Ironically, the property is at the site of St. Elizabeth's Hospital, the first federal insane asylum in the United States. But once a bureaucracy has a piece of real estate and builds buildings, it's game over. They're just going to accrete and grow and grow, so that's one indication. The trend is clearly in motion.

It's all over for the US. In fact, let me say this. America doesn't exist anymore. What is left is not even these United States. That was decided in the 1860s. It's the United States.

America, which is basically an idea, a concept, is dead and gone. The United States is just another of 200 awful little nation-states that have spread across the face of the earth like a skin disease. There's no longer any difference that I can tell between the US and any other country.

TGR: How would you describe the concept that America was based on that is now gone? And is there another country in the world embracing that concept? Will there be a new America?

Doug Casey: No, there is no other place. I've been to 175 countries and lived in 12. My feeling is that the best thing that you can do is set your life up so that you're not to be considered the property of any one government. You might have a passport or several passports and, therefore, that government thinks they own you. But if you don't spend time in a country, practically speaking, there's nothing they can do about it.

So no, there is no real haven for freedom in the world today. The best you can do is go where the governments are so unorganized that they can't control you effectively. That's one reason I like to spend time in Argentina. They have an incredibly stupid government, but they're also very inefficient and ineffective. So it's wonderful as a place to live.

I also spend time in Uruguay, because it's a tiny little country with no ambitions to conquer the world. The nice thing about New Zealand, where I am now, is that it's a small country, only 4 million people, lots of open land. It's got some severe problems, but it's pleasant. I think the US is going to be the epicenter of a lot of problems in the years to come.

TGR: Few of our readers are probably in positions where they could live in 12 different countries, but they have amassed assets here in the United States. What advice would you give them to safeguard those assets?

Doug Casey: The key is to remember that we're going to have a long and deep depression, so most things that worked well over the last 20 years are unlikely to work well in the future. I'd been predicting the real estate collapse for a long time. It's still got a way to go, too, because a lot of real estate debt remains that has to be liquidated. There's a lot of leverage out there and there's been a huge amount of overbuilding. So it's far too early to get into real estate, at least in North America or Europe.

It's also way too early to get into the general stock market, for all kinds of reasons. Dividend yields are still extremely low. Earnings are going to collapse. Government bonds are perhaps the worst single thing to be in, because with the government printing up money literally by the bushel basket, the Dollar is going to start losing value radically and interest rates are going to start going up radically at some point. So you have to rule out most stocks.

I'm afraid that the most intelligent thing you can do is to own a lot of gold, including Gold Coins in your own possession. And I think speculation in Gold Mining stocks makes sense at this point, because gold stocks are about as cheap as they've ever been relative to other assets, really, in history. Now is an excellent time to do that as well. But that's in terms of speculation.

Investment risk is tough enough, but the biggest problem is political risk. That's what you have to watch out for. That means you have to diversify internationally. This is harder for most people, harder psychologically, and it takes more assets to make international diversification viable. But if you're in a position to do it, it's the most important thing you can do.

TGR: Are you recommending putting all of your investment in gold into the bullion or are you also recommending some portion in producing junior and exploration stocks?

Doug Casey: Both, but look at the stocks as being speculative. Most of your money should be in gold with a bit of silver, too. Silver is basically an industrial metal, but it has monetary characteristics. Now is the time to be very overweight in the metals and I think owning gold stocks is a good idea. They're very cheap.

TGR: Anything else investors can do to preserve whatever may remain of their wealth?

Doug Casey: Owning real estate in some foreign countries is a very good idea – from a lifestyle point of view, an asset diversification point of view, and a possible capital gains point of view, too. They can't make you repatriate foreign real estate. Having some US Dollar cash while we're going through this deflationary period is very wise as well, but that's not going to last. Eventually the US Dollar is going to reach its intrinsic value.

TGR: Not that you have a crystal ball, but how would you see the rest of '09 playing out?

Doug Casey: Nothing goes straight up or straight down, but it seems that '09 is going to see much higher Gold Prices and much lower stock prices and much lower bond prices, too. But remember, the worst is yet to come.

You haven't heard an awful lot about people losing their pensions yet, but that's going to happen because what are pensions invested in? They're mostly invested in stocks and bonds and commercial real estate. All three of those things are disaster areas, and bonds are the big disaster area yet to come.

So I think it's going to be nothing but bad news in 2009. What happened in 2008 was just an overture to what I think is going to happen in '09 and '10.

TGR: Even into 2010?

Doug Casey: Yes. This isn't going to be cured overnight, mainly because of what the government's doing. As I said, it's perversely exactly the opposite of what they should be doing, which is abolishing all the agencies and freeing up the economy. They're passing lots of new regulations, they're going to have to raise lots of taxes eventually, and they're inflating the currency. So it has to last, at least into 2010. It's going to be quite dismal, actually.

TGR: And what happens with the unfunded Medicare liabilities?

Doug Casey: They're not going to be funded. They're going to be defaulted on and, actually, that's the best thing that could happen. That's one of the things that should be done now; the US government should default on its debt. This is shocking for people to hear, but it wouldn't be the first time the US government has done that. It did that almost at its founding in continental days.

This debt represents a tax liability that's being foisted off on the next generations who have no moral obligation to pay and should not pay. I think as an ethical point, the US should default on this debt. It's impossible to pay it back, and it won't be paid back. It's more honest to acknowledge that bankruptcy now as opposed to pretend it's going to be paid back. Defaulting even might forestall runaway inflation in the dollar, which would be a catastrophe of the first order. So it's the smart and moral thing to do, and it's going to happen eventually anyway. All the real wealth will still be here; a lot of it will just change ownership. The big losers will be those who lent to the State, thereby enabling its depredations, and they deserve to be punished.

But even a default tomorrow will do no good unless you put the US government into reverse and disband all of these ridiculous, destructive agencies that have grown like a cancer for years. Taxes should be cut 50% to start with, just out of hand. And the defense establishment – it's a misnomer; it's not defense at all but rather foments wars around the world – should be cut hugely. Not with a butcher knife; but a chain saw. But none of this is going to happen; in fact, just the opposite. That's why I'm so pessimistic now that the tipping point's finally been reached.

TGR: Are we at the tipping point?

Doug Casey: Yes, we've absolutely gone over the edge. The consumer is no longer in a position to consume. Everybody is going to cut consumption to the bone and hopefully find something to produce instead. It would be better for people to start viewing themselves as producers than consumers. That would be a step in the right direction to get them psychologically more in line with reality.

TGR: In last fall's meltdown, Gold Bullion held up, but the gold-mining stocks didn't. Quite a few producers and soon-to-be producers, and some companies making discoveries, seem to have bottomed out in November and December. But worry persists in the market. Suppose another shoe drops or another black swan appears? Richard Russell of Dow Theory Letters and others have been talking about the Dow going down to 5,000. What would that do to the gold stocks?

Doug Casey: Gold Mining stocks are also stocks, and the best environment for gold stocks historically has always been when both gold and the stock market are going up. But since the last gold stock bull market came to an end, I think it's entirely possible to see a bubble develop in gold stocks with all the money being created. I certainly hope so. I'm actually optimistic for gold stocks just because they're so cheap relative to everything else.

TGR: They have been beaten down...

Doug Casey: Yes. And that fact, along with the waves of money being printed around the world and the much higher gold prices we are going to see, could cause a speculative mania to develop in the gold stocks. Nobody's even thinking about that possibility right now, because they're so battered. But this is the time to get into the right ones because it's likely to happen in the future.

TGR: The 1929 crash – which was really the preamble, because '30, '31, '32 and '33 were certainly bigger – is when gold stocks such as Homestake did their best. How do you see that playing out this time around? Is it different this time or do you expect a similar pattern?

Doug Casey: You know what they say, "History doesn't repeat itself, but it rhymes." I think that, first of all, the gold mining industry is a much worse industry now than it's ever been in the past, because just as all the easily defined light sweet oil basically has been discovered, all the easy-to-find high-grade gold basically has been discovered. Most mines that are going into production are low-grade, which means that you have to move a lot of dirt, which means that they're much more capital-intensive than in the past. So gold mining's a worse industry from that point of view.

Also, politically speaking, with the rise of the green movement, there are people who don't want any oil burned, any dirt moved, any trees cut. They don't want to see anything happen. This makes it much harder to do gold from a permitting and political point of view. We're in a much higher tax environment than in the past. So it's a tough industry. It really is. It's just a 19th century choo-choo train type of industry that interests me only as a speculative vehicle. You'll notice that gold went from lows of about $300 to highs of about $900 and none of these gold companies are making any money because their costs actually went up faster than the price of gold.

So I'm not saying Gold Mining is a great business. It's not. It's a crappy business. Still, we could have a bubble in the stocks. I'm hoping we do.

TGR: Aren't we going to see a change in that in '09? Oil, which is one of the large components of that cost, has come down dramatically. A lot of these producers must be locking in oil at these lower prices. Won't that translate into year-over-year earnings increases for the gold producers?

Doug Casey: That's possible. The producers actually may show increases for the next couple of years. I don't doubt that. But I don't think oil will stay where it is. I think oil's eventually headed back to $150 a barrel or more.

TGR: So why wouldn't you own oil as well as gold?

Doug Casey: It's a good idea, but we weren't really talking about oil. I'd say that oil is a good thing to own. Oil is a real buy now. It's as good a buy at $40 as gold is at $900 right now. Maybe a better buy; who knows?

TGR: If we go into worldwide depression, will oil continue to be a good buy or will it self-regulate around this $40 a barrel?

Doug Casey: I am bullish on oil. Although I'm philosophically not very sympathetic to the peak oil theory, I think it's a geological fact. Also, China and India and the other developing parts of the world don't use a whole lot of oil now. As they develop, they will to want – and almost need – to use a lot more oil. That's going to keep pressure up on the demand side. But the supply side actually finally is constrained, so it's going to mean higher prices. In a depression-type environment, US and Western oil consumption could drop a lot, but the third world would take up most of that slack. So I have to be bullish on oil.

TGR: Are you bullish on any other sectors or commodities?

Doug Casey: I'm bullish on agricultural commodities. They ran way up last year and then collapsed again. I think a good case can be made that most of the soft commodities are quite cheap and will go higher, so I'd look at those, too. I think gold definitely, oil in the years to come has the potential to go much, much higher, and the agricultural commodities have a lot of potential.

TGR: Gold appears to be uncoupling from the US Dollar. Historically, when the Dollar was strong, gold would be weak. But we've had a couple of recent instances in which both the Dollar and Spot Gold have been strong. Obviously, we've seen a total decoupling of gold from oil. It used to be when oil was running, gold was running and vice versa, but that no longer seems to be the case. Is that just an old wives' tale or is something going on?

Doug Casey: I've never seen any necessary relationship between gold and oil, just like there's no necessary relationship between rice and natural gas, or nickel and soybeans. All these commodities tend to move together, all the currencies tend to move together and stock markets tend to move together, but they all have their own dynamics. I think it makes sense to compare the relative prices of various commodities and see what may be cheap or dear relative to other things based on the fundamentals.

On any given day, somebody may have to buy or somebody may have to sell a huge amount of almost anything. It's unpredictable and you can't tell what constraints are out there in the market. I don't even pay attention to day-to-day fluctuations because they're just random noise. I watch the big trend. It's been shown that if you just made one correct trade and stuck with it at the beginning of every decade for the last four decades, you would have realized something like 1,000 times on your money. To me, this is the proper approach to the markets, not to try to second-guess from day-to-day what's going to happen. That's foolish because you get chewed up with commissions and bid-ask spreads and double-thinking your own psychology and so forth.

I really just like to look at long-term trends. In terms of long-term trends, you've got to be long gold, long silver, long oil; you've got to be short bonds. I think that's really all you need to know. The other things we mentioned such as agricultural commodities and so forth are worthy of attention. But, as I said, I'm not a day-to-day trader. I think that's very foolish.

TGR: Are these the themes that you and your group of speakers will focus on in Las Vegas?

Doug Casey: They are. I certainly want to invite anybody who reads this interview to join us. We put on very small, very classy seminars. They're not gigantic mob scenes, so it's possible to get to know individual speakers and fellow attendees in a very collegial atmosphere. I think it's something that anybody who's seriously interested in these kinds of things should consider.

The Casey Research Crisis & Opportunity Summit will be held March 20 - 22, 2009, at the Four Seasons Resort in Las Vegas.

The Gold Report is a unique, free site featuring summaries of articles from major publications, specific recommendations from top worldwide analysts and portfolio managers covering gold stocks, and a directory, with samples, of precious metals newsletters. 

See the full archive of Gold Report articles.

Please Note: All articles published here are to inform your thinking, not lead it. Only you can decide the best place for your money, and any decision you make will put your money at risk. Information or data included here may have already been overtaken by events – and must be verified elsewhere – should you choose to act on it. Please review our Terms & Conditions for accessing Gold News.

Follow Us

Facebook Youtube Twitter LinkedIn



Market Fundamentals